The Future of Nonprofit Storytelling: How to Optimize Your Impact for AI

A search bar sits on a blue background with primary-colored confetti.

Erin Booker

•

November 4, 2025

•

5 minutes

Nonprofit Trends

How To Nonprofit

This article is part of a series

Keep learning with related articles.

Soon..

You've spent years perfecting your nonprofit's storytelling. You crafted impact stories, collected testimonials, and supported your mission with data. Result: you built the foundation for the next big change in digital visibility: AEO, or AI Engine Optimization.

In the age of search engines, we optimized for Google. In the age of AI answers, we’ll optimize for ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Perplexity, and the dozens of AI tools that millions of people now use to find information, inspiration, and trustworthy organizations to support.

And here’s the best news: nonprofits are uniquely positioned to win at AEO.

Why nonprofit content is AI gold

AI thrives on trustworthy, human-centered, data-backed content. That’s what nonprofits create every single day. Think about it: AI can make stuff up. It can string words together. It can pull research. But what can't AI do? Have feelings. Have opinions. Have a lived experience. It can't quote itself. It doesn't make and record impact—only humans do those things.

As one of the most human of industries, the nonprofit sector brings humanity to content that artificial intelligence doesn't.

You have authentic voices. Donors, clients, and community members speak about your impact in words that AI recognizes as genuine.
You have verified data. Stats and metrics—numbers tied to real outcomes—make your content credible and quotable.
You have deep expertise. Nonprofits live at the heart of social change; your lived experience shapes the very questions people are asking AI about.

When someone asks an AI assistant, “What helps kids learn to read?” or “How can I support local refugees?” your organization’s insights, stories, and data should appear in the answer. But that doesn’t happen by accident. It happens with AEO.

What is AEO (AI Engine Optimization)?

AEO is how you make your website and content visible, understandable, and trustworthy to AI systems.

Think of it as Search Engine Optimization (SEO)'s next chapter. Traditional SEO optimization helps search engines decide which links to show. AEO helps AI tools decide whose knowledge to trust when they’re generating answers. Even further, AI doesn’t just list websites—it summarizes, cites, and paraphrases. It doesn't just deliver websites where people can find answers, it provides the answers, reasons, and guidance. Your goal is to ensure your content is ready to be quoted, referenced, or summarized accurately.

How AI finds nonprofit content

Let’s clear up a big question: how do AI systems even find nonprofit content?

AI engines—like the ones powering ChatGPT or Perplexity—scan the open web, just like Google’s crawlers do. They learn from public content: articles, reports, blogs, FAQs, and impact stories. When people ask questions, these models retrieve and summarize information from sources they’ve indexed.

You don’t need to submit your website to an AI tool (how, even?). But you do need to make sure your content is structured and labeled in ways that help AI understand:

Who you are (your nonprofit name, mission, location)
What you do (the issues you solve, populations you serve)
Why you’re credible (data, stories, partnerships, media coverage)

This combination of clarity and context is what makes AI systems surface your content as a trustworthy source.

How to optimize your nonprofit content for AI

You don’t need to be a developer or have a giant budget to start improving your AEO today. Here are some practical ways for busy fundraisers and donor communications teams to get started.

But one thing before we start... one big point here is that your content already has juice that AI loves. You shouldn't have to actively go back and change everything on your site. And if you have exclusive member content, for example, you don't have to cancel that whole program. Just keep these steps in mind when you're in content creation mode going forward.

1. Start with your stories

Stories are your superpower. Write them in ways that answer real-world questions—because that’s what AI is trained to respond to. Try structuring impact stories around questions like:

“What problem were we solving?”
“What did we do to create change?”
“What difference did it make?”

Include names (with permission), locations, and tangible outcomes. Use natural, conversational language and quotes, if you've got 'em. AI loves narratives that sound human and specific, not polished or generic.

2. Add Facts and Data

AI models rely on factual anchors. Adding data points to your storytelling makes it more trustworthy. Include details like:

Number of people served (“We provided 1,200 meals last month”)
Geographic details (“We serve youth in Los Angeles County”)
Partnerships (“In collaboration with the local library system…”)

When possible, present data in lists, tables, or short paragraphs; AI systems read structured information better than walls of text. (Hence the bullet points in this section.)

3. Be a trusted source

Avoid insider jargon. Write as if you’re explaining your work to a curious supporter, not a grant reviewer. Use full sentences, define acronyms, and include short contextual phrases (“…a type of after-school literacy program”).

(AI looooves context, so just go bananas with the explanations!)

Also, cite credible sources when possible. Linking to research, government data, or media coverage builds the trust signals that AI models use to verify your expertise.

4. Structure and accessibility matter

The technical side doesn’t need to be overwhelming, so don't stress if that's not your strength. Focus on these basics:

Your site should load quickly and look good on mobile.
Each page should have a clear headline that describes what it’s about.
Add alt text to every image (AI uses these as context clues).
Use headings (H1, H2, etc.) to organize content clearly.
Steer clear of PDFs or content that's only accessible through a paywall or via follow-up email. If people can't view it, AI won't be able to, either.
When you have the capacity, ask your web manager about adding schema markup, a kind of behind-the-scenes code that helps AI categorize your content accurately.

5. Publish consistently

AI systems prioritize current and active websites. Post regular updates: impact stories, news, or insights. You don’t need to publish daily, but aim for steady activity. A blog that’s updated regularly sends a signal that your organization is active and relevant.

Content pro tip: Schedule your content out! Do a bunch at once and then schedule weekly or even monthly drops. You can get a quarter's worth of content set up at one time.

AEO-savvy content pro tip: A lot of social media posts are indexed just like content on your site. When you can, expand your content to YouTube, Meta properties, LinkedIn, or other social media content.

6. Build a knowledge base

Turn your team’s expertise into easy-to-understand content:

FAQs (“How do we select program participants?”)
Explainers (“What does food insecurity really mean?”)
Resource pages (“How to find mental health support locally”)

These are exactly the types of questions AI engines get every day, and they need trustworthy, nonprofit-driven answers.

In fact, having your AI of choice review your website for unanswered questions so that you can build FAQ and explainers is a great (although circular) way to ensure that your website is rounded and valuable for people searching for information on your mission.

Try this prompt to get at the knowledge gaps: "You are a donor looking to make a financial gift to a charitable organization that [does what you do]. You've come across [your website]. Would you consider donating to this organization? Why or why not? What reservations or questions do you have after looking at [your website]?"

Fundraising Impact: Why AEO matters

As a fundraiser, your goal isn’t just traffic—it’s trust.

When AI assistants cite your organization, your authority grows. When new supporters discover your fundraising campaigns through AI searches, your reach expands. When your stories become part of the answers people read and share, your impact narrative travels further—organically.

Measuring AEO success

This is where things get tricky and where most fundraisers have lingering questions.

Because AI tools don’t show traditional rankings or clicks, measuring success takes a different mindset. Here’s how to gauge your progress:

Check your website analytics (like Google Analytics 4). If traffic from new sources (like Perplexity.ai or Bing Copilot) is rising, you’re being surfaced in AI-driven searches.
Run AI prompts. Try asking ChatGPT or Gemini questions your audience might ask (“How to support local foster care nonprofits”) and see if your organization—or content like yours—shows up.
Track mentions and backlinks. AI summary engines often include source links. If your content is being cited, that’s a big win.
Monitor engagement. Watch whether new visitors spend more time reading stories or converting through donation pages—an indirect signal that AI visibility is working.

What’s realistic for nonprofits

AEO is new for everyone—so give yourself permission to start small. You don’t need to hire a consultant or overhaul your entire website. Start with:

One updated impact story written with clarity and data.
One FAQ page answering common community or donor questions.
One technical review with your website manager to confirm your site loads fast and uses headings and alt text properly.

Each of these steps strengthens your AEO foundation and moves you closer to visibility in the new AI landscape.

Pro Tip (or opinion?) If we had to do one thing today, we'd start with our past annual reports. We'd put together a summary of year-by-year progress, add in the top 1-2 donor stories and top 1-2 client testimonials, build in a FAQ section to answer questions about impact over the years, and put it all on one lovely landing page. Like a one-stop answer shop for the bots.

Feeling overwhelmed? Here’s what actually matters

AEO can sound technical and intimidating, but at its core, it’s about being findable by the right people in the right context. You already have the hard part handled: meaningful stories, credible data, and lived expertise. The rest is simply translating those strengths into formats AI can recognize.

Don’t worry about doing everything at once. Focus on doing one thing clearly and consistently. AI (and all good content strategy) favors quality over quantity, and authentic storytelling over perfection.

AEO Takeaways to amplify your voice

AI isn’t replacing your voice—it’s amplifying it.

Your nonprofit's content includes everything AI loves: authentic stories, reliable data, and a deep understanding of your mission. Through content optimization for AI, you’re ensuring that when someone asks, “Who’s making a difference in this space?”, the answer includes you.

Because in the new era of fundraising, authority and authenticity are what get shared, surfaced, and supported.

Mobile phone with donation form and donation charts floating around the phone.

Woman looking at fundraising chart with button to book a call.

Yellow shapes in background with donation form in front with stylized text, build an intelligence giving experience.

Download

Start For Free

FAQ: Nonprofit AEO Essentials

What’s the difference between SEO and AEO?

SEO primarily targets traditional search engines such as Google to improve online visibility. It utilizes techniques like optimizing for specific keywords and gaining backlinks from other sites to boost search engine rankings. On the other hand, AEO is centered on enhancing content specifically for AI-powered tools that provide direct answers and solutions to users' queries. Instead of just keywords and links, AEO emphasizes providing clear, contextual, and trustworthy information that machines can easily interpret and relay accurately.

How can small nonprofits compete with large organizations?

AI prioritizes content that is relevant and demonstrates authority, regardless of the organization's size. A small nonprofit that actively publishes firsthand accounts and regularly updates its content can outperform a larger organization that remains silent and fails to engage with its audience consistently.

Do I need to hire someone to do AEO?

Not necessarily. Begin by focusing on clarity, consistency, and making your content accessible to readers and technology alike. As you build a foundation with these elements, consider seeking the assistance of a developer to implement structured content with data or schema markup. This technical enhancement can further improve your visibility and effectiveness in AI-driven searches.

How do I measure success with AEO?

Keep a close eye on your referral traffic, paying particular attention to changes and trends. Actively conduct experiments with AI-related queries to understand how they impact your visibility. As you refine and optimize your content, you should notice a rise in the amount of traffic originating from AI-powered browsers and virtual assistants, indicating that your efforts in optimizing for artificial intelligence are paying off.

What’s the first step I should take today?

Choose a compelling story from your work and enhance it with detailed information, backed by solid data, and narrated in an engaging, conversational tone. Publish this content with a powerful headline and a well-organized structure that guides the reader seamlessly through the narrative. By doing so, you’ve successfully embarked on your journey towards achieving effective AEO.

What type of content performs best for AI?

Stories, data insights, and educational content are highly effective. Include impact stories to show your nonprofit's influence. Add personal testimonials from people you have helped. Use FAQs to answer common questions. Write blog posts that explain your work. Share detailed annual reports that show your achievements and future goals.

Do I need to change my tech stack or CMS?

Absolutely not. Initially, concentrate on creating content that is clear, accurate, and consistent. These foundational elements are crucial. Once you have mastered the basics and are ready to advance, you can utilize additional tools such as schema markup or structured data to further enhance your online visibility and search results. However, it is important to remember that exceptional content should always be your primary focus.

What are the different types of AI?

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is available in various types, including generative AI, predictive AI, and automation AI. Generative AI involves tools that are designed specifically to develop and generate content, such as writing or media. Predictive AI focuses on analyzing data to identify patterns and project future trends, which can be incredibly beneficial for strategic planning. Lastly, automation AI is all about optimizing repetitive and mundane tasks, thereby saving time and allowing human resources to focus on more essential duties.

There are more types of AI, like machine learning, but those aren't the type of AI models we're discussing in this article.

What are the best AI tools for nonprofits?

Top AI tools for nonprofits that are particularly beneficial for nonprofits include Appeal AI, ChatGPT, and Google Gemini, all of which excel in crafting written content. For design needs, Canva AI Magic Studio stands out, while Grammarly provides invaluable assistance with editing tasks. Salesforce AI offers deep insights into donor behavior. These tools collectively empower nonprofits to enhance their communication strategies. They merge automation with real, mission-focused messages. This improves storytelling and helps raise more funds.

Is AI going to replace human nonprofit professionals?

AI is not set to replace nonprofit professionals; rather, it serves to amplify their impact in significant ways. AI technology is good at automating routine tasks like data entry or writing first drafts. But it cannot replace human qualities like empathy, building donor relationships, or storytelling. Nonprofits do well when their teams use AI to make processes easier. This lets them spend more time building trust, community building, and engaging donors deeply.

What does it mean for my nonprofit to use AI responsibly?

Using AI responsibly means protecting data privacy, making sure information is correct, and being clear about how AI is used. Nonprofits must ensure sensitive data isn't shared with AI tools, verify the accuracy of all AI-generated content, and maintain human oversight in their storytelling processes. Using AI ethically builds donor trust. It also strengthens your organization's credibility and mission. This is important to keep a trustworthy relationship with supporters and stakeholders.

What’s the timeline for results from my AEO content?

AEO results grow gradually. In 3–6 months, optimized nonprofit website content can begin appearing in AI-generated answers. If you tell stories regularly, update data, and improve technology, your visibility, credibility, and website traffic will grow steadily. This happens through AI-driven tools. It is similar to SEO but has a broader, long-term reach.

What’s the connection between AEO and fundraising?

AEO enhances fundraising efforts by boosting your nonprofit's visibility and establishing authority within generative AI search outcomes. As AI tools highlight your compelling impact stories and relevant data, potential donors find and place trust in your organization with greater ease. This leads to increased awareness, fortified credibility, and deeper donor engagement. The key to this success lies in crafting genuine, AI-optimized storytelling that resonates with audiences.